Showing posts with label Finance / Accounts / Taxation / Law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Finance / Accounts / Taxation / Law. Show all posts

Thursday, 27 November 2014

To prepay or not to prepay?

Is Prepayment is wroth-while option.?? Factors to be decided before taken the decision.
Given the Indian aversion to debt, it is hardly surprising that many loan owners are eager to prepay their loans as and when their finances look up. However, this is not always the most economical option and one should consider various factors before deciding on this course.

What is prepayment?
When a borrower pays off his/her loan entirely or in part before the defined due date, it is termed as prepayment.
When considering prepayment, borrowers need to ensure that they factor in the following aspects:
  • Prepayment penalties
    Prepayment penalties vary from one financial institution to another, and often, even from loan to loan. These penalties are either charged at a flat rate, or at a certain number of months' interest. Even if the loan contract does stipulate a prepayment fee or penalty, a loan owner must first compare this amount against the overall interest he/she will save in terms of interest. Also, in some instances, the prepayment is made possible after a minimum stipulated period of loan ownership. To make sure they are able to capitalise on these provisions, borrowers must first carefully read their contract or talk to their borrower at length.
  • Actual savings
    Loan owners often presume that because they have already paid a substantial number of EMIs, the interest component is much lower, and it hence makes little sense for them to prepay the loan amount. The truth, however, is that the borrower pays the same interest for the unpaid principal amount, since the interest is calculated using the reducing balance method. When considering prepayment, borrowers should hence consider the prevailing interest rate, rather than the loan tenure.

    Whether or not to prepay your loan depends on many factors such as the stage of loan payment you are at, the interest rate, and the prepayment charges. An analysis of these elements is a must before you decide to take action.

Monday, 24 November 2014

Understanding Reverse Mortgages

Once a person has crossed his (her) earning years, but has not planned for the retirement years, or financial planning has gone awry due to heavy unforeseen expenses/losses, or inflation has taken away the purchasing power of savings etc., what does he (she) do to live the remaining years on this planet without seeking handouts from near and dear ones? Even if one bites the bullet and seeks financial assistance from his own children, whether they will respond positively is a moot point in this age of nuclear families.
If you had the good sense to invest in a residential property instead of say making fixed deposits in a bank, there is a retail banking product called Reverse Mortgage (RM) which can provide you financial security in your twilight years. The idea is not new. Even though this product has not taken off here in India, despite the pioneering work done by National Housing Bank (NHB), it does not take away the merits of this product. Banks have not been very aggressive in marketing this product and many people are not even aware of RM. Actually, this product has more relevance to India where there is no social security net. Surprisingly, this product originated in developed countries and in USA, for example, there are dedicated reverse mortgage companies.
RM is also a loan against property. But it is not the same as a loan against property. The basic difference between the two is summarized below.
  • Loan against property is normally not extended by banks to senior citizens. But RM is specifically targeted at senior citizens. Only senior citizens are eligible for RM.
  • Loan against property by way of housing loan is extended to acquire a property. But RM is extended against a property which is already owned.
  • Loan against property needs to be repaid in EMI over agreed tenure. But in RM, the proceeds of the loan are paid to the customer in installments or lump sum as agreed. There is no EMI.
  • RM is cleared out of foreclosure or repayment. There is no EMI. Loan against property is to be cleared in EMI, and foreclosure is the last resort when loan is not repaid.

The Concept

In a traditional house mortgage transaction, there is an EMI fixed and payment of your EMI increases your equity in the property. Reverse mortgage, as the name suggests, does the opposite. You start with say 100% equity in the property and when loan disbursal starts, your equity in the property goes on decreasing. The target group for RM are the senior citizens owning house property either singly or jointly without any encumbrance on it. Abroad, one can take a RM loan on an encumbered property also, provided it can be paid off from part proceeds of the RM and sufficient equity is available. The collateral is the property itself. In other words, when processing an application for such type of facility, the market value of the property is taken into account rather than the repayment capacity of the borrower. The loan generally does not have to be repaid until the last surviving homeowner permanently moves out of the property or passes away. But banks generally fix a long tenure. The estate (i.e., heirs to the property) has approximately 2 months to repay the balance of the reverse mortgage or sell the home to pay off the balance. Any remaining equity is inherited by the estate. The estate is not personally liable if the home sells for less than the balance of the reverse mortgage. That is why when arriving at the quantum of the reverse mortgage loan, sufficient cushioning by way of margin is stipulated. The age of the homeowner at the time of making the RM loan available and remaining life expectancy is another aspect which needs to be looked in to. A 70 year old applicant is eligible for a, higher  quantum of loan on a property with same market value compared to say a 60 year old applicant. The property offered as collateral needs to be evaluated by a qualified engineer approved by the bank not only for assessing the current condition but also the residual life. The property taxes, insurance are to be  serviced by the home owners along with general maintenance.

The Product

Let us now look at the RM product offered by some of the leading Indian Banks. Theguidelines to Indian banks on RM have been framed by NHB, an entity which came into being through an act of parliament. It's capital is 100% contributed by RBI. Some of the guidelines are mandatory and need to be followed by lending institutions like commercial banks and housing finance companies registered with NHB.
  • Eligible borrowers should be senior citizens, that is 60+ years old. The property offered should be a self-acquired, self-occupied residential property free of any type of encumbrances with clear title, and all taxes paid till date. In the event of financing a couple, one should be a senior citizen and the other should be at least 55 years of age. The residual life of the property, as certified by lender's valuer, should be minimum 20 years.
  • The quantum of loan shall depend on the value of property, age of the borrower, residual life of the property, rate of interest, requirement of a margin of not less than 10% throughout the life of the loan, and maximum tenure of 20 years. Property needs to be revalued once in 5 years and it is to be ensured that such revaluation does not bring down minimum margin of 10%. If the property value falls during the tenure, then the quantum of RM will need to be reduced.
  • RM can be disbursed in agreed installments, in lump sum or tranches or through committed line of credit (LOC). The installment is currently capped at ₹50,000 per month. Lump sum payments are restricted to medical exigencies and capped at 50% of amount eligible with maximum quantum being  pegged at ₹15 lakhs.
  • Interest rate on loans may be floating or fixed and no ceiling has been prescribed. In other words the interest rate shall be market determined.
  • The disbursements under RM shall not attract any income tax. Basically, RM disbursement is loan disbursement and not an income.

Advantages and disadvantages of RM

Advantages It provides a stream of payments and provides financial security when a senior citizen has no other source of income or source of income is inadequate. The disbursals are tax free. There is no repayment involved as property is sold and loan is adjusted. One can receive disbursements as per his convenience. Instead of taking RM loan if one sells the house, then he needs to pay capital gains tax and also move out of the house. If sale proceeds are invested, then the income from investments may be subject to income tax. The borrower/legal heir shall not be held liable to lender if sale proceeds are less than the amount owed under RM.

Disadvantages Interest on RM is not subject to any tax rebate. The disbursement proceeds need to be used for specified purposes only. If one outlives the tenure of RM, one is at the mercy of lender. If the borrower passes away, the property will be sold by lender, unless legal heirs arrange to repay the loan. Mortgaged properties, when sold by banks, do not fetch the actual market value. There is no system of RM counseling before availing the loan, and as a result one may be in for unpleasant surprises later on. When you have acquired the property with your hard earned money with some sacrifices, it is difficult to contemplate it being sold by the bank. When property is sold to repay the loan, the proceeds will attract capital gains tax.

Conclusion

Perhaps, because of the sentiments attached to the property, senior citizens may find it difficult to accept the idea of property being sold if they outlive the tenure of the loan. Helpage India provides counseling for RM to senior citizens, but most people are not aware of it. The life expectancy has grown due to better medicare. There may be hardly any equity available after property is sold and loan is cleared, for a senior citizen to survive financially in the remaining life span. There are a number of issues including taxation which needs to be addressed before the product can have universal acceptance. Even though, at the nudging of NHB, many commercial banks in public and private sector have this product in their portfolio, actual assets in this category may be one or two per bank! Perhaps it may be worthwhile for RBI to encourage establishment of RM companies, after ironing out some of the taxation issues with finance ministry.

Sunday, 16 November 2014

Fixed or Floating? Which is the better option?

Whether to choose fixed rate of home Loan or a floating rate of interest is a question faces by every loan seeker..!!
Whether to choose a fixed rate home loan, which allows you to clearly plan your budget, or to choose a floating rate of interest that provides the benefits of decreased interest rate, is a question that perplexes every home loan seeker.

Types of fixed interest loans
There are two types of fixed rate loans: one that remains constant throughout the loan period, and one that is subject to review periodically. Usually, the interest charged is higher in the former than in the latter. For instance, a permanently fixed rate loan may cost you 14 percent interest, whereas a loan with a rate that is reviewed every three years may come at 13 percent. Moreover, there may be restrictions on the amount that can be prepaid in case of both types of fixed rate loans.
Most loan owners are tempted to lock their interest rate for the entire loan tenure and not depend on market conditions for their EMIs. However, after a few years, if they feel the need to switch to a floating rate of interest, lending institutions allow them to do so after paying certain charges or fees.

Which is the best option for you?
Finally, it is up to the borrower to decide on what suits him/her the best. Ideally the borrower should compare home loans for various parameters and understand every single detail about it. If certainty and security are prime considerations, a fixed rate home loan will be the best option, however it won't come without the premium on interest rates

Saturday, 15 November 2014

SBI MaxGain – It is advisable to go for Home saver loans..!! & Pre Payment Vs Parking Surplus Funds..

Most home loan borrowers face the dilemma of whether to use their monthly savings to prepay their loan or set it aside for emergencies. In most cases, the extra money just sits in their savings accounts earning below par (and taxable) interest. A home saver loan lets you have the cake and eat it too. You will be able to park this amount in the home loan account for any number of days and pull it out anytime for your urgent needs or regular expenses when they become due (e.g., paying kids school fees every quarter). The money thus kept in the home loan account reduces the total interest outgo on your home loan and helps you close your loan faster.

MaxGain is a popular home saver loan product from SBI. Similar home saver loans, albeit with different interest rates, are also available from other banks including Citibank (Home Credit), Standard Chartered Bank (HomeSaver), HSBC (Smart Home) and IDBI Bank (Home Loan Interest Saver).

We will focus exclusively on SBI MaxGain in this article. Other home saver loans listed above are quite similar and may differ in minor details. Before we delve deeper into SBI MaxGain, let's understand what is an overdraft (OD) account.

What is overdraft (OD)?

An overdraft facility is a credit line provided to individuals against their assets. You can think of it as being similar to a credit card with a limit but without the interest-free (grace) period. i.e., the interest clock starts ticking as soon as the amount is withdrawn instead of waiting until the payment due date. The interest rate on overdraft account is typically lower than credit card. You can withdraw money upto the sanctioned limit and will have to repay the outstanding balance along with interest only for the duration that you utilize the money from the account.

How is SBI MaxGain different from regular home loans?

SBI MaxGain is a home loan that is sanctioned as an OD with a limit that is equal to the approved loan amount. Your home acts as the underlying security for the OD account. This product has the same interest rate as the other home loans from SBI upto Rs. 1 crore (as of this writing). A premium of 0.25% is applied for home loans above Rs. 1 crore. There is no extra charge for use of OD facility. The current account (OD) comes with cheque book and net banking facility.

Home saver loans are suited for those individuals:

  • whose earnings aren't constant – self-employed or businessmen. At a recent real estate expo, SBI told me that MaxGain isn't available for the self-employed and businessmen.
  • who have a periodic (quarterly, semi-annual or annual) bonus or variable pay component that can be parked in the OD account.
  • who have savings after paying EMI and other monthly expenses.
  • NRIs and professionals with higher income.

How does monthly payment work?

A typical MaxGain account statement looks like this:

DescriptionSBI H L MAXGAIN AUG11
NameMr. FIRSTNAME LASTNAME
Book Balance-14,62,750.00
Available Balance1,00,366.00
Limit15,63,116.00
Uncleared balance0.00
Drawing Power15,63,116.00
CurrencyINR
Rate of Interest (% p.a.)10.3%
Lien Amount0.00

Here are a few points to help understand the how monthly payment works:

  1. Upon final disbursal, your Limit and Drawing Power will equal the sanctioned loan amount. These amounts will reduce with each EMI payment.
  2. Drawing Power = Outstanding principal loan amount.
  3. Available Balance = Any surplus amount parked in this account + accrued interest savings. More on this below (Point 5 thru 8).
  4. Book Balance = Drawing Power – Available Balance. This is shown as a negative (minus) amount.
  5. Your monthly EMI will not vary despite surplus amount in the OD account.
  6. Principal portion of the EMI is applied on the date of EMI payment and goes to reduce the Drawing Power and the Limit. The principal portion of the EMI is calculated as per the original amortization schedule. Surplus amount deposited in the OD account and accrued interest savings do not alter the principal portion of the EMI.
  7. Interest portion is calculated against the Book Balance on a daily basis and is debited at the end of the month.
  8. All surplus money parked in the home loan account goes towards Available Balance. Even if the surplus amount is kept only for a few days during the month, it helps reduce the interest component of the EMI for that month. Since the interest is calculated on the Book Balance instead of outstanding principal, any excess amount (i.e., EMI – Principal – Interest) is added to the Available Balance.

Here's a comparison of amortization schedule (first 24 months only) of regular home loan and SBI MaxGain:

Comparison of amortization schedule of regular home loan vs SBI MaxGain

Amortization schedule (first 24 months only) of regular home loan vs SBI MaxGain
(Click to enlarge)

We will assume that both home loans have the same principal amount, interest rate and tenure. As you can see from the schedule, the borrower does the following deposits into (and withdrawals from) his SBI MaxGain account during the first 24 months:

  1. Deposits a surplus amount of 2,00,000 at the beginning of month-6
  2. Withdraws 1,00,000 in month-12 for his kid's school fees
  3. Withdraws 1,00,000 in month-17 for family vacation
  4. Gets a salary hike and starts depositing 20,000 each month from month-18
  5. Withdraws 1,20,000 in month-24 to pay his kid's school fees

Although the borrower has withdrawn all the surplus money that he deposited at the end of month-24, he still has interest savings (Available Balance) of 19,529.72. You cannot achieve such results using the regular home loan.

Regular Home Loan

SBI MaxGain Home Loan

1

EMI includes two components: Principal and Interest. The principal component increases and the interest component decreases with each successive payment. EMI remains constant throughout the loan tenure.

Same as regular home loan.

2

Principal and Interest components are calculated as per the original amortization table.

Principal component is calculated as per the original amortization table. The Drawing Power is reduced by the principal amount of the EMI each month.

Interest component, however, varies depending on Book Balance.

3

Interest is calculated on the outstanding principal loan amount (as in the original amortization table).

Interest is calculated on the Book Balance on a daily basis and is debited at the end of the month.

Excess amount from the monthly payment (i.e., EMI – Principal – Interest), if any, is applied towards the Available Balance.

4

Principal and Interest components are applied on the EMI payment date itself.

Principal is applied on the EMI payment date itself whereas Interest is debited at the end of the month. Until then, the entire interest portion is shown as part of the Available Balance.

5

Cannot be used like SB or current account for outgoing transactions and bill payments.

You can use the home loan account to do funds transfer (NEFT, RTGS etc.) and bill payments using cheque book and net banking facility. Available Balance is the limit for such transactions.

6

Home loan is closed when the outstanding principal amount is zero.

You can approach the bank to close your home loan when the Book Balance reaches zero.

Pre-payment vs Parking Surplus Funds

Pre-Payment (in regular home loan or MaxGain)

Parking Surplus Funds in SBI MaxGain

1

Reduces outstanding Principal Balance.

Increases your Available Balance and reduces your Book Balance.

2

Your amortisation schedule changes. You can opt to reduce either your loan tenure or loan EMI.

1) If you opted for lesser loan tenure, then more of your future EMI goes towards Principal.

2) If you opted for lesser EMI, your future EMI (and consequently your principal and interest portions) will reduce.

Your amortisation schedule remains unchanged. However, more of your interest portion goes towards Available Balance.

3

The money is gone forever. You cannot undo this action.

You can withdraw the surplus amount at any time. Your amortisation schedule remains unchanged. Now, less of your interest portion goes towards Available Balance.

4

Tax deductible under Section 80C.

Interest savings are not tax deductible.

Advantanges of SBI MaxGain

Liquidity

If you make partial prepayment on your home loan, that money goes to reduce the outstanding principal and is not available to you anymore. However, any surplus funds parked in MaxGain home loan account can be withdrawn anytime.

However, surplus fund deposited before full disbursal or for under construction property cannot be withdrawn until complete disbursal. Your interest outgo will reduce because of this deposit and interest saved will get added to available balance, but you cannot withdraw till you get possession.

Interest Savings

If surplus funds are parked in the OD account, it saves interest outgo on the home loan. Helps you close the loan faster.

Better yield than other deposit / investment products

Interest saved is interest earned . Experts recommend this product over other investment products including tax free bonds and FD.

Instead of opening a Fixed Deposit (FD) for 1-5 years, if you park the same funds in the OD account, you will get 1 to 3% higher savings. Note that you will be realizing this rate even if you park your funds temporarily unlike FD where you will pay a penalty for premature withdrawal. On top of that the savings with MaxGain are tax free.

Tax deduction

Any amount that you deposit to Maxgain will not be treated as "pre-payment" under Section 80C. Hence, that amount does not qualify for Section 80C rebate. Experts advice that you should only park amount over and above the tax deductible interest portion. Interest saved (as shown under Available Balance) is not tax deductible under Section 24.

Friday, 14 November 2014

Inflation effct on You

Inflation can be defined as across the board sustained increase in prices of domestic as well as imported goods and services and fall in the purchasing power of the home currency. Inflation rate can be measured through a benchmark price index. It can be wholesale price index (WPI) or consumer price index (CPI). A price index is the weighted average price of select goods and services in a given region, during a given interval of time. The change in the weighted average compared to a base period in percentage terms gives an idea of price movement of the basket of goods and services in the index. In our country, the central bank and the government were tracking the movement of the index taking into account the wholesale prices. This can be misleading as the retail or consumer level prices are the ones that  impact the purchasing power in the hands of the individual citizen. In India, the components of the two indices are also not similar. WPI has got several components such as food items, non-food items, power and oil etc., which aren't part of the CPI. In developed countries inflation is tracked based on the CPI.  Now RBI has switched over to CPI as a benchmark for inflation. The gaps in data integrity and difficulties in collecting data notwithstanding, WPI was serving as a barometer to the purchasing power parity of the Rupee versus other foreign currencies when calculating real effective exchange rate (REER) of the Rupee. RBI now wants to track the REER taking in to account the CPI. This means the REER will reflect the under or overvaluation of Rupee with the ground level inflation rate. Inflation is the single most important factor influencing the exchange rate. This is  because a weak Rupee results in higher import costs.

The weightage for different components in WPI  in July 2014 were as follows:

ParticularsWeight
Primary Articles20.12
Fuel and Power14.91
Manufactured Products64.97
Total100

Energy imports are the biggest contributor to CAD. Increased energy costs further contribute to rise in prices and consequently inflation. Fuel and Power alone contributed nearly 15% to total weight. This impacts the price of primary articles and manufactured products as well. Energy costs impact every facet of the economy directly or indirectly. Since country is heavily dependent on import of petroleum products, the government has no control over prices of these commodities and subsidizes the consumption.

Inflation has a direct impact on household budgets, as it results in increased spending on household goods and services on the one hand and reduced surpluses for savings and investment on the other. The return on investments, especially in fixed income securities like term deposits, debentures, bonds etc. may turn negative when inflation rate is factored in, as majority of debt instruments yield a fixed coupon. This causes an interest rate risk when market interest rates rise or fall on account of inflation/deflation. To tame inflation by reducing money supply, the central bank will increase the CRR and administered interest rates, resulting in increased cost of borrowings by banks and financial institutions as money supply gets reduced. These will be passed on to the customers who end up paying higher EMI, further decreasing the purchasing power and investible surplus. The manufacturing sector will be impacted on account of higher borrowing cost, higher cost of imported inputs and lower demand. Ultimately, the national gross domestic product (GDP) will fall, and if remedial steps are not taken, it may lead to stagflation, or inflation coupled with stagnation in economic activity.

How Does Inflation Occur?

Many economists propound the theory that easy money conditions, or increase in money supply causes inflation. That is, too much money chasing available goods and services causes more money supply and in turn reduces the purchasing power of the Rupee. It impacts most those who have less money to start with. When the government earnings are less than its expenditure, it results in fiscal deficit. This gap needs to be bridged by the government by borrowing through issue of bonds, foreign aid, overseas government to government borrowing, borrowing from multilateral agencies and increased taxation. Bonds are bought by the financial institutions and banks by using the savings which citizens have deposited with them. In other words, government manages its affairs by borrowing from the financial market. The money raised is used by the government for planned as well as unplanned expenses. The expenditure which does not result in investments, gets used up for consumption and fuels inflation. Good examples are subsidies to sectors that do not deserve it. This government expenditure beyond its means, results in more money supply and consequently erosion in the value of money and inflation. This inflationary pressure impacts those who have less money the most, and increases poverty. More taxation results in less money in the hands of consumers leading to lesser demand for goods and services, causing a falling GDP. It also results in weakening of the rupee versus other major international currencies. As can be visualized, inflation impacts every economic activity.

Another school of thought says inflation is on account of demand exceeding supply for goods and services. To illustrate this theory, let us examine Bangalore city as a classic example. 25/30 years ago Bangalore was a sleepy pensioners paradise and quite economical to live in compared to say, Mumbai. Then came the IT influx. IT companies started hiring people from all over the country at high salaries, because good talent was not plentiful, and demand exceeded supply. This created a class of people with high purchasing power who were looking to spend their high income on luxury food and drink, personal transport, premium housing etc. They then brought their families to settle in Bangalore, and suddenly there was exponential growth, especially in the real estate market. Land prices zoomed to astronomical heights, as Malls, gated communities, hospitals, schools, apartments, shopping complexes, hotels, commercial complexes, bars and restaurants, furniture shops, boutiques, spas, salons etc. sprang up all over the city. Carpenters, plumbers, painters, electricians, drivers, watchmen etc. are in high demand and in short supply. Service providers are dictating their own prices and creating benchmarks. Prices of vegetables and fruits have gone up astronomically, as supply cannot keep up with demand. The purchasing power of rupee has fallen drastically, and the poor have been pushed to the outskirts of the city or slums are created. This situation is replicated in other parts of India including tier two cities. This demand has created purchasing power in the hands of real estate developers, landlords, service providers, professionals etc. and in fact a large and mixed population of the city. Now that there is an ever growing demand for goods and services, and supply is limited, the economic reality of falling purchasing power of the rupee can be felt by the population of these cities in particular and the country as a whole.

How Does Inflation Impact You?

If you are an employee working in the private sector, your salary will not be inflation proof. The employer measures your emolument based on the cost to company or CTC. The components of the CTC unfortunately do not have an inflation allowance!  You will have to submit your annual performance appraisal  and hope for a good raise in your basic pay, so that you will be able to manage your household expenses despite the erosion in the value of money. You may have to take a re-look at what expense is towards a "necessity" and what expense can be postponed. Every company may not have the pricing power and may report lower profits. It means, the raise you were hoping for may not happen, or may not be to the extent you were hoping for. A part of the raise is taken away by the government by way of direct and indirect taxes.

In the case of public sector employees, among other components of the pay, they receive a dearness allowance. Based on the consumer price index, this allowance changes at periodical intervals. Does this insulate government servants from inflation? Not fully, as the index does not fully reflect the erosion in the purchasing power of the Rupee. Plus, the income tax takes away some portion of the DA. Sometimes this DA increase may push you to a higher tax slab, and your net pay may become less than what it was before the DA increase!

If you are a businessman, the postponing of purchases by consumers will mean less revenue for you. Of course, certain businesses that have the pricing power will not be impacted much. Take cigarette companies for example. Whatever be the excise increase, they pass on the entire burden to the consumer, and their profitability hardly gets impacted. Or, take the example of a daily consumption article of a family, like milk. Even though households may grumble, they do not curtail consumption, because it is a necessity at whatever price. But families do reduce expenditure on entertainment, going out etc., and postpone buying luxury articles.

If you are young and your talents are in demand in the job market, inflation may not impact you much. This is because, your pay packet may get a hike sooner than later. But if you are mediocre, and you are easily replaceable you may get the axe sooner or later. Companies tend to cut what they term as "flab" in an inflationary environment with falling growth. If you are a retired person, you have a lot to worry about as you have to depend entirely on your balance sheet.

Inflation and Investments

One should invest in a residential house/apartment which is an effective hedge against inflation. The value of a house only appreciates in tandem with rise in inflation. This is because the cost of all the materials which go into building a house would also have gone up due to inflation, and a new dwelling will cost much more than what you have invested in before inflation set in. Sale of a house should generate good capital appreciation in an inflationary market environment. Renting your house should also give you good return, considering that in an inflationary market the rentals would have also gone up. Reasonable level of inflation is actually good for the real estate market. REITsunits, when available for investment, should  also provide good hedge against inflation.

Another asset class, which can help you in an inflationary economy, is equity shares. Even though demand slump may impact earnings of some companies, there are some sectors that do not get impacted. A good example is FMCG, pharmaceutical and FMCG and Pharma contract manufacturing companies. The share prices of companies in this sector go up during inflationary trends. You will get dividend income as well as capital gains in such investments. You see, people will not stop buying toothpaste, soap, shaving cream, medicines etc. just because prices have gone up by a few rupees. But they may postpone buying an asset like a car  because they can still use a two wheeler or public transport. Investment in FMCG and pharma funds can be an alternative to direct investment in the stock market.

RBI had issued inflation indexed bonds in 2013 of ten year tenure, and extended it up to March 2014. These bonds are indexed to CPI instead of WPI. These bonds are long term and there is no secondary market for it and illiquid. The interest is taxed as per extant IT rules. Early redemption is allowed after minimum 1 year for super seniors and 3 years for others with penalty cut. This product, even though designed as a hedge, has a number of deterrents and may not suit all. If you are keen on investing in such instrument, you will need to wait for next issue by RBI. RBI did not find much demand from retail investors for this security, even though it was made available on tap for retail investors.

Tax free bonds which give a return higher than the inflation rate can also be examined as an alternate investment avenue. But these bonds give low returns, are long term and have interest rate risk. But for an HNI in 30% tax slab, it may make sense to invest in these instruments.

Traditionally, gold is considered to be the best asset class to invest in when all else fails. That is why international prices of gold tend to go up in a global economic downturn. In India, gold jewellery is considered as part of the family wealth, and given to a bride as dower. But gold jewellery is not a liquid asset and it does not generate any income. It needs to be melted and  gold separated from other additives when selling. You will get a lower caratage and a lower price. Investing in gold bars and coins is not advisable because of the ever changing government policies. The current duty structure has made smuggled gold cheaper than what you can buy across the counter. Stocking physical gold is risky. Alternatively one can look at gold ETF.

Conclusion

A little inflation is actually good for the economy, compared to a deflationary trend. A good example of deflationary market is Japan, which has a large geriatric population. Domestic consumption is negative and country's economy is wholly export dependent for growth. After emergence of China as the largest exporter in the world, Japan has lost its importance. Even at practically zero interest rates, Japanese economy is not picking up. Yen is used by speculators for carry trade.

But, inflation level in India needs to be brought down from current levels if any sustained economic growth is to be achieved. Research indicates that inflationary conditions may not abate for at least a couple of years. So, plan your investments and expenditure wisely and reduce the impact of inflation on your household budget.

Thursday, 13 November 2014

An Introduction to Savings and Investments – Part 2

We discussed some of the traditional investment products in the first part of this article. In continuation of where we left off, we shall look at some other investment avenues. To start with, let us look at another popular plain vanilla product – Recurring Deposit (RD). This product is available with all the banks with some variations. The variations are minor and relate to minimum monthly deposit, the rate of interest, the minimum tenure and closure before maturity rules.

Recurring Deposit – the convenient way to save

As the name suggests, you invest a round sum every month till the contracted period. RD is basically a term deposit product, wherein instead of making an individual term deposit every month, you build up savings through a differentiated product. The maturity value of the deposit is indicated upfront. On maturity, you get the principal amount plus interest in one lump sum provided you have paid the installments regularly on due dates. The interest is compounded quarterly. The main attraction of this deposit is for salary earners, who can deposit a fixed sum every month by giving a mandate or standing instruction to the bank to debit their transaction account. RD interest is exempted from TDS. However, you need to add this accrued interest to your annual income and pay tax on it, based on which tax slab you are in. You can pay tax either every financial year based on accrued interest or at maturity based on the aggregate interest. Banks generally give loans against RD (maximum loan is principal plus accrued interest less margin) at a rate which is 1% higher than the contracted interest rate for RD.

There is no special advantage in this product vis-a-vis a reinvestment term deposit, other than the convenience of a mandate or standing instruction. However, it may be mentioned that you get the contracted interest for the tenure of the  deposit, even though later deposit installments have shorter tenure.

This product is regulated by RBI and IBA.

Gold – The promise of wealth!

Do Indians consider gold as an investment? If so, why do they invest in gold jewellery instead of gold bars, biscuits and coins? Gold jewellery is not a liquid investment. It is difficult to sell gold jewellery for cash. Even if it is possible, the net amount you get will be after deducting making charges etc. which you had paid when buying the jewellery. These can be as high as 20 to 25% of the amount you originally paid. Not a good idea to buy gold jewellery as an investment option. Of course, in case of emergencies you can raise a gold loan by pledging the family jewels.

What about gold coins and bars? This is a better option than buying jewellery. However, while banks sell gold coins and bars, they do not buy them. It is therefore advisable to buy from reputed jewellers with a guaranteed buyback and guaranteed 99.9% purity. The main drawback of investment in gold is that, you do not get any return by way of a coupon or dividend as in other investments. You have to only look for capital appreciation. The average return for a medium term holding in gold may be in the range of 10 to 12% PA. Sometimes the wait can be quite long, if you invested at the peak prices. The price of gold in India is influenced by international prices, the exchange rate for USD/INR, the customs duty, VAT etc. Holding physical gold is fraught with the risk of pilferage. Or you may have to hire a bank locker to keep them safe. Banks do not give loans against gold coins and bars.

You have a choice of investing in paper gold through gold  ETF, gold fund of funds or gold equity funds. Gold equity funds are not traded in India, because we do not have listed Indian companies directly engaged in gold mining, refining etc. Therefore we shall examine ETF and Fund of Funds.

To invest and trade in Gold ETF, you need to have a trading account with a broker and a demat account. Brokerage and Demat charges are additional charges. ETF is a mutual fund product whose units can be bought and sold in the exchange. One unit represents one gram of gold. The units can be redeemed for physical gold only if it is for a minimum quantity of a kilogram of gold.

Fund of funds is one where you need not have a trading or demat account. You are investing in a mutual fund which invests in Gold ETF. The gold fund of funds have underperformed the ETF due to several reasons. It is therefore advisable to invest in an ETF rather than fund of funds.

ETF is taxed like a debt mutual fund. Capital gains where the holding is less than a year is considered as short term capital gain, and gains beyond an year of holding is considered to be a long term capital gain. You can take indexation benefit in the case of long term capital gain as applicable to a debt fund.

Gold in physical form or paper form are attractive when inflation rates are high. This is because gold is considered as a safe haven when all other asset class fail, and demand pushes up the prices.

Initial Public Offering or IPO – The taste of things to come?

You can invest in equity shares or corporate debt instruments through the secondary market or through the IPO route. For both, you need a Demat account. To sell or buy these securities in the stock exchange, you need a trading account. This product is regulated by SEBI.

When a company goes public, it invites applications from the prospective investors after SEBI has approved the issue. A company approaches a merchant banker for all matters connected with the issue including the pricing. The issue also gets rated by a rating agency, which of course does not venture into the pricing aspect or guarantee the ROI. The main terms of the issue are spelt out in the document called the prospectus, or red herring prospectus when it is a book built issue. The difference between the former and latter is that one is an issue at a fixed price, and another is an issue where the price is arrived at through a process of price discovery wherein bids are made through a syndicate. The application for the shares can be made either through an application form submitted physically along with payment to the banker to the issue or through online banking under ASBA. ASBA stands for Application Supported by Blocked Amount. The amount of application money is blocked by the bank from your savings account and you continue to earn interest on it. The blocked amount will be either used to pay for allotted shares or refunded in the case of non-allotment. Only self certified syndicate banks, whose names are listed by SEBI, can accept ASBA. As per current SEBI guidelines, an issue is reserved for allotment to the extent of 10% of issue size to small investors. A small investor is one who has applied for shares whose value does not exceed ₹2 lakhs. These rules provide better chances of allotment for smaller applications. But many a times, investors have burnt their fingers by subscribing to shares that have subsequently tanked in the secondary market. This main risk in IPO is now addressed by SEBI by making it mandatory for issuer to have a buy back arrangement in place up to 1000 shares to original allottees up to 6 months from listing as a safety net.

What are the advantages and disadvantages in subscribing to IPO?

The main advantage is that the minimum amount of investment is not large. Unlike secondary market investment, you save on brokerage and STT. You can take advantage of price movements on initial listing, provided it is at a premium to issue price. Losses can be minimized through safety net. You can apply through ASBA and online banking with minimum hassles. You may be lucky enough to invest in a multi-bagger. The investment is quite liquid. The short term capital gain tax is 10% and there is no long term capital gains tax.

The disadvantage is that most good IPO are very highly priced and there is hardly anything left on the table for the investors. Most issues by well known names get highly oversubscribed, and either you get a refund or you are allotted a very small number of shares limiting your gains. You must have a demat account. Transaction costs include brokerage, STT when you sell your IPO shares.

There are professionals who invest in IPO for listing gains and make it their regular activity. There is also a thriving grey market for IPO shares.

Corporate Debt – The fixed income story

Companies issue debt instruments called debentures and bonds. They mostly offer a fixed interest return. Debentures may be partly or fully convertible into shares. Such instruments are called hybrid instruments. Debentures can also be non-convertible, secured or unsecured. They may be redeemable or irredeemable. You rarely see irredeemable debentures or bonds. These are issued by some reputed MNC banks for their tier II capital. Some debenture issues may carry tradable share warrants for subscribing to shares of issuer at indicated price, which would be lower than the market price. Corporate bonds listed in the exchange provide easy liquidity. You can subscribe to IPO of corporate debt instrument or invest through the secondary market. You can increase your yield on investment by going in for debentures and bonds from secondary market which are available at a discount to issue price. Debt instruments issued require to be rated as per SEBI guidelines. A highly rated paper which is secured carries a lower default risk, and can give a steady interest stream. This investment is attractive if you are risk averse and require an uninterrupted fixed income. You need to have a demat account and a trading account for trading in corporate debt.

Current tax laws require TDS to be deducted on interest from debt instruments. TDS may not be deducted if the instrument is issued in demat form, but you need to add the interest income to your taxable income. Capital gains tax is applicable to both short term and long term investments. Indexation benefit can be availed for long term capital gains. Since this is a fixed income investment, it is subject to interest rate risk.

Company Fixed Deposits – The icing on the cake

Listed companies can accept deposits from the public subject to the provisions of the companies act and SEBI regulations. There are a number of well rated companies accepting deposits at interest rates much higher than that offered by your neighborhood bank. However, they are much more risky compared to a bank FD. They are also not liquid as compared to a bank FD. In a bank FD, an investor has an embedded option and can close the deposit before maturity, or a depositor is entitled for a loan against deposit. These facilities are not available with company deposit. There is no TDS on bank deposits if aggregate interest income of all deposits is less than ₹10,000. In a company deposit, the threshold limit is ₹5,000. Interest income is taxable in both the cases. You have the flexibility of depositing for a minimum tenure of 7 days and maximum of 120 months in a bank. Company deposits have a minimum tenure of 1 year and maximum of 3- 5 years.

The higher interest rate offered by corporate is offset by the advantages of a bank deposit. Still if liquidity is not an issue and deposit is for a short term, well rated company deposits are a good option.

Conclusion

Which product or asset class is the best out of the lot is debatable. It is dependent on your risk appetite, investment profile and your time horizon. These articles are meant to give you an input on the pros and cons and how the product works. You will have take your own decision as to where to put your hard earned money or consult an investment advisor. In the next part, we shall discuss some additional products such as sovereign bonds, overseas investments, structured products etc..